Throughout my teenage years and even a few years into my adulthood, monogamy (a relationship with only one partner) was the only form of love that I knew existed. It wasn’t until becoming more active online that I became aware of polyamory, which is an intimate relationship with multiple partners, all who consent to said relationship. When I first heard of this form of relationship, I wasn’t sure what to think of it. Personally, I have only ever been comfortable with a single partner whom I would dedicate all my love to, and have that love from them in return. But, that’s just what works for me. When it comes to polyamory I figured, if everyone knows what’s going on and is okay with it, then it can undoubtedly be a great thing. I didn’t give it much more thought until I found out that my friend David and his wife lead a polyamorous lifestyle. Naturally, I had plenty of questions about how everything works, and David was kind enough to allow me to interview him.
What were the circumstances that lead you to a polyamorous lifestyle?
My wife and I had been dating for around 7 months when somewhat out of nowhere, she broke up with me and started seeing this other guy. A few very tumultuous months later, that would take way too long to describe, they had broken up after my wife realized how awful of a person this other guy was, we were still incredibly close friends, I was still madly in love with her, and my wife was still insisting that we not get back together. What was so puzzling for me was that for all intents and purposes we were back together. We loved each other, and said it, we went out together all the time, we spend time with each other’s family, and we even started back up some of the physical parts of our relationship. Finally once night about 5-6 months after we broke up I asked her what was the big issue with saying we were officially “back together”? My wife’s answer was that she loved me more than anyone she’d ever loved before and could see herself spending the rest of her life with me. I, being puzzled, by that answer as a reason not to get back together pushed a little further and got the clarification, “I’m too young to be with the last person for the rest of my life”. We were only 20 at the time and as much as I didn’t like it, her answer kind of made sense. So I suggested after about a second and a half of deep contemplation, “then let’s not be the last people for the rest of each other’s lives”. I wouldn’t say that was the moment we became poly but it was certainly the circumstances that led us down that path. We didn’t even hear of the word polyamory for another 5-6 years. We always struggled to figure out what term to use to describe ourselves and my wife still makes fun of me for running downstairs one day after watching a documentary saying with probably more excitement that appropriate, “there’s a word for what we are!”
Do you tend to enter into a new romantic relationship together with your wife, or do you each have separate partners outside of the relationship? If separate, how much interaction do you have with each other’s partners, if any?
It has certainly been both. We’ve dated the same person, we’ve dated other poly couples, and we’ve both dated individuals completely independent of each other. When dating separate partners outside of the relationship, there has usually been a fair bit of interaction with the other partner. My wife has dated some men who were actually far closer friends with me before they started dating then they were with her. That hasn’t always been the case and there have also been outside partners who, usually because of time and/or distance, don’t have that much interaction. Basically my wife and I are best friends, so even in situations where, for example, I’m dating someone where there isn’t mutual attraction between them and my wife, they still interact with her as much as they would if I was room-mates with my best friend. The same has gone the other way as well.
Do you and your wife need each other’s consent before you enter into a new intimate relationship?
Consent’s a tricky term in that context. It’s almost like asking do we need each other’s consent to become friends with someone. I guess ultimately the answer would be yes because if my wife ever forbade me from dating someone, I wouldn’t. That being said, if my wife ever forbade me from dating someone, we would likely have a very long conversation about what’s going on because that would be so incredibly out of character for her. The same thing applies in the other direction. What does happen is that we are always talking about our own and each other’s feelings. By the time anything intimate would ever happen with an outside partner, we’ve discussed it many many times. As an example, there was recently a situation where I had started dating someone new. My wife and I had talked about it several times but just before I was going over to my new partner’s home, my wife pulled me aside and said, “I know I’ve said in the past that I was ok with you doing [x] with your new partner but because we haven’t been spending as much time together lately, (work and kids had been crazy for both of us), I think I will have a difficult time emotionally if you go past [y]. I’m not forbidding it or anything; I just want you to know how I’m feeling”. We talked a little more so I could double check to make sure if my wife didn’t want us stopping even earlier than that line. I told my new partner how my wife was feeling and she agreed that it was important to respect my wife’s comfort levels. I guess it helps that I would never date anyone who wouldn’t.
When you begin a new relationship outside of the marriage, is it generally understood by all parties that it will be temporary, or do some become long term relationships?
I try to enter all friendships with the hope that the friendship will last the rest of my life and acceptance of the fact that statistically it likely won’t. When those friendships have the added potential of being with someone I might fall in love with, the first part becomes stronger and the second part becomes even more important. Just like many single people starting a new relationship, there are different expectations with different people but I never plan for something to only be temporary.
Are there ever circumstances where either of you struggle with jealousy? If so, how do you overcome it?
I often chuckle when I explain what poly is and get the response, “I could never do that because I feel too much jealousy”. It’s kind of like saying, “I could never eat a healthy diet because I’m too hungry a person”. Jealousy has been a fading issue for both my wife and I over the years. It’s a completely natural emotion but like the desire to eat a dozen doughnuts in one sitting, it’s one that giving into reduces happiness in the long term. I think the greatest defence against jealousy is something called compersion. Compersion is a term the joy one gets when seeing one’s partner experience happiness caused by an outside source. My wife sees me excited about reading a really great book, she may get a little miffed about the time I’m spending on it but her being happy for me outweighs that. In the same light, when I see her come home from a date grinning ear to ear, I may feel a twinge of jealousy but that’s nothing compared to how great it feels seeing someone I love that happy. The last thing I will say on the jealousy question is that in many ways being poly creates fewer reasons for being jealous. I actually was reminded of this when I first met up with you to discuss this interview. When I told my wife I was going out at 1 in the morning to visit with a woman and “talk about an interview”, her response was, “don’t forget you’re bringing the kids into daycare tomorrow”. She had no reason to be jealous because she knew I had no reason to lie to her about my activities. I imagine a lot of monogamous couples, although certainly not all, would have more difficulty in that situation.
Was there ever a time when your marriage was threatened by another relationship? If so, how did you get through it?
Nope. Our marriage has certainly had rough patches but I don’t think they have ever been caused or even made worse by another relationship. The opposite is certainly true though. When we were going through a miscarriage many years ago, we certainly grew closer together as a couple but that closeness was absolutely helped by having the love and support of another couple we were dating at the time.
How much do your children know about your polyamorous relationship? How do you handle it if they have questions?
Our intent is to be very honest with them. I’ve talked to some monogamous people about that who seem somewhat shocked by the idea of honesty with our kids but the conversation is all about context and being age appropriate. Our kids are quite young, our oldest is almost 4, so there are certain things they don’t understand. Obviously I won’t be graphic about intimate details but neither do mono people when their kids ask questions. We also don’t see a lot of value in making a big deal about the distinction between intimate partners and any other friends. My wife and I try to be very social people and the vast majority of our friends are 100% platonic. In the vast majority of social circumstances there aren’t a lot of differences between those 2 types of friendships. When our kids are old enough to ask the questions that can distinguish the types of relationships we will answer them but until then, when they see me hugging a friend who stayed in our guest room overnight, they have no reason to know the difference between a friend who didn’t want to drive home because of bad weather or a friend that stayed over because my wife was kissing them goodnight.
What is the biggest challenge you have encountered as a polyamorous couple?
Time. Love is infinite, time is not. Typically we both try to make sure that any time spent with outside partners is not taken from the time with our family. So if I’m starting up a new relationship, my video game playing time typically takes a big drop. It also means some negotiating though. I mentioned earlier that recently we had a situation where my wife needed to pull back some of her boundaries. That was 100% related to our work schedules having been completely opposite to each other’s for a couple months and us not having enough quality time together. That was certainly an unusual blip for us though.
What is your favorite thing about being in a polyamorous relationship?
The number one thing is getting to see the look on my wife’s face after she has just had a first kiss with someone new. My second favourite would be getting to have an amazing wife who is my best friend, a perfect lover, and an incredible mom while also getting that nervous scary energy that comes from starting a brand new terrifying and wonderful adventure with someone new. Finally it’s also pretty brilliant getting to then share those experiences with someone I love.
What is your least favorite thing about being in a polyamorous relationship?
Watching someone I love get their heart broken. Imagine how awful it feels to get dumped and then multiply it by watching it happen to someone you love. The only time in the past decade I’ve seriously considered not being poly anymore was right after a really painful break-up my wife went through. At the end of the day though, that thought is no different from a non-poly person whose heart’s been broken thinking about being single forever. Love is too wonderful to give up on even if it’s painful sometimes.
What advice would you give other couples considering polyamory?
Have a really solid relationship first. The old saying goes that you can’t love another until you love yourself; well the poly corollary is you can’t have two successful relationships until you have one. Being poly magnifies things. The great part is that it magnifies the joy and love within a relationship. Having extra relationships creates a feedback loop where each person not only gets to feel their own love and joy but also that which is reflected back from others. The downside is that the negative stuff is magnified too. If there were trust issue before poly, they will be twice as bad once you are poly. Essentially think of all the things that are needed to make your relationship successful and expect to need more of it. Of the key relationship skills that are needed in any relationship, mono or poly, the 2 most important when being poly are communication and time management.
A big thank you to David for opening up about living a polyamorous lifestyle. It’s always interesting and educational to learn about lifestyles that are different from our own, and the people participating in those lifestyles. What might seem strange or scary to one person can be completely normal and perfectly healthy to another person. There is no single right way to live. Whether you are straight, gay, monogamous, polyamorous, transgendered, bisexual, or something else: if you’re happy, then you’re doing it right. Thanks for reading.